Crime Connect | South Africa
Luxury goods belonging to businesswoman Shauwn “MaMkhize” Mkhize have come under scrutiny after a Sandton boutique owner questioned the authenticity of many of the designer items being auctioned in Pretoria as part of efforts to recover outstanding tax debt owed to the South African Revenue Service (SARS).
David Leven, who owns a high-end luxury boutique in Sandton, attended the auction at Mooikloof, Pretoria, and said he believed many of the handbags, shoes and accessories on display were not genuine. He claimed that approximately 90% were fake, although he acknowledged that the estimate came partly from information shared by a friend who had previously conducted authentication work for SARS. His estimate has not been independently verified.
The auction, conducted by Bidders Choice, features 418 lots of luxury goods previously belonging to Mkhize. The collection includes handbags, shoes, watches, jewellery, sunglasses, clothing and other accessories, with brands such as Hermès, Prada, Fendi and Cartier represented in the sale.
Bidders Choice managing director Pieter Geldenhuys confirmed that the items in this particular auction could not be authenticated. He explained that goods which had been authenticated were sold separately in an earlier auction, while the items in the latest sale were kept apart because their authenticity could not be established.
Several people attending the auction also questioned the quality and authenticity of certain products. Reports highlighted concerns about the appearance and condition of some Hermès handbags, while other bidders said they believed some of the designer goods were not genuine. However, these observations do not establish that the items are counterfeit.
The distinction is important: an item that cannot be authenticated is not automatically proven to be fake. Leven’s 90% estimate remains his claim, and Bidders Choice’s explanation confirms an authentication limitation rather than a finding that the entire collection is counterfeit.
The auction forms part of SARS’ efforts to recover more than R125 million in outstanding personal, corporate and family trust taxes linked to Mkhize and associated entities.









Leave a Reply